The Middle Class Money Trap: Why Growing Up Comfortable Made Me Bad With Money

Hey {{first_name|Reader}}.

Getting personal today with another money/personal finance piece. Each week, you encourage me to share more details and I must say, it makes me feel great to get some of this off my chest.

When I was 12, my parents moved us into a 3,500 square foot house in the nice neighborhood. I thought we were rich. I thought we'd made it. Twenty-six years later, as a 38-year-old dad with three kids, I see it completely differently: that move wasn't wealth. It was lifestyle creep wrapped in respectability. And it taught me everything wrong about money.

(I’m always looking for feedback. Let me know! Reply to the email.)

Growing up middle class sounds safe, but it secretly screws you by blinding you to real struggle on one side and real wealth on the other. It cushions you just enough that you never see what true poverty feels like and never get close enough to the ultra-wealthy to understand how they actually think, live, and teach their kids. Research shows that middle class kids grow up in a unique psychological space: protected from hardship but excluded from the knowledge that builds generational wealth.

When I was a kid, my parents were textbook middle class. Both were public servants with four-year degrees and master's degrees, plugged into secure systems that rewarded you for showing up, doing your time, and not rocking the boat. We originally lived in a modest house in the woods, drove to the beach once a year, and it all felt…normal.

Then, when I was 12, we leveled up. We moved into a 3,500 square foot house in the nice neighborhood and started taking annual trips overseas to tropical places. I thought we were rich. In my head, the story was simple: do well in school, go to college, get a good job, and then coast through life in a big house with vacations as your reward for being a respectable adult. Studies on income and parenting show this is a common middle class narrative—upward mobility through education and professional achievement.

Looking back as a 38-year-old dad with three kids, I see it completely differently. What looked like "we made it" was actually lifestyle creep and keeping up appearances. New cars every time one was paid off, home renovations, the bigger house because that's what successful people do. Without realizing it, my parents were teaching me how to be bad with money and how to build a life where your entire existence revolves around working so you can keep consuming. The middle class has gotten worse off precisely because of this pattern.

The unspoken money rules in my house were clear: college is non-negotiable, get a good job, and a pension is the ultimate ticket. We did not talk openly about money. We did not talk about ownership, assets, or building something of your own. The script was: become a highly educated, well-paid employee, plug into a system, and stay there until they hand you a gold watch and a retirement party. (which isn’t even a thing anymore)

When I look at my peers from similar backgrounds, that's the through-line: we were "set up" to make other people money. We were groomed to be the reliable middle managers, the professionals, the ones whose professional destiny always sits in someone else's hands. College wasn't presented as one tool among many; it was the only path. Trades, entrepreneurship, community college, even the military were framed as backup plans. (until they came with scholarships that fit the respectability script)

No one ever said, "You should build something, not just work for something." No one framed life as: work for yourself and build your job around your life, not build your life around your job. Research on social reproduction shows that middle class parents often inadvertently teach their children to remain employees rather than owners.

On top of that, there was the pressure. In my world, I wasn't supposed to be "well-rounded"; I was supposed to be elite, at grades, sports, and the college trajectory. By middle and high school, it was obvious to me that my worth in adults' eyes was tied to my performance and my potential résumé, not who I was as a person. Studies on affluent youth show this pattern clearly.

That kind of achievement pressure is common in upper-middle class families, where kids grow up with high expectations but also intense anxiety and fear of failure. Research demonstrates that adolescents from affluent or upper-middle class backgrounds often report elevated rates of stress, depression, and substance use because their value feels contingent on constant achievement. In my case, it dug in deep: I developed a low self-image that followed me well into adulthood. I didn't feel like I was choosing my path; I felt like I was executing someone else's script out of fear of being labeled lazy, stupid, or entitled.

Here’s a quiet trap of the middle class: you're told that saving is virtuous and that investing is "important," but nobody teaches you how any of it actually works. In my house, money conversations were basically: spend on the life you've earned, and save what's left if you can. There was no talk of assets, ownership, compound interest, or tax strategy. Parents pass on bad money habits to their kids—especially when those parents were never taught wealth-building themselves.

So when I got my first real adult job, I did what I thought successful adults did: I went out and bought a new car. 2013 Nissan Altima. (38 mpg!) I didn't understand the buying process, how to negotiate, or what financing would actually cost me over time. That's not because I was dumb; it's because no one had ever walked me through it. Research shows that many parents pass on their own incomplete or unhealthy money habits to their kids, especially around spending versus saving, because they themselves were never taught how to build wealth through investing and ownership.

Poor families often teach their kids that every dollar matters and that hard work is about survival. Ultra-wealthy families, when they're intentional, teach their kids how money works: investing, leverage, equity, and taxes. The middle class tends to sit in the uncomfortable middle, enough money to feel safe, but not enough knowledge to break out of the earn–spend–save treadmill. Income-based parenting differences are well-documented across economic classes.

By the time I was a teenager, I could see the arms race clearly. New cars in the driveway. Kitchen upgrades. Bigger houses in better neighborhoods. Yearly vacations where everyone tried to outdo last year's destination. All of it said, "We are doing well. We are winning." The middle class is objectively worse off than previous generations, yet consumption signals have only intensified.

At 12, my parents stretched to move into that 3,500 square foot house in the "nice neighborhood." That move, like so many middle and upper-middle class decisions, wasn't just about square footage; it was about status, school zones, and being seen in the right places. Sociologists have documented how middle and upper-middle class parents pour resources into housing, schooling, and activities to signal success and secure advantages for their kids, often at the cost of financial flexibility and long-term security.

What kids internalize from that is simple and dangerous: a good life equals constant upgrades. You work to afford the upgrades. You don't question whether those upgrades are actually making you free.

In my house, there was only one acceptable narrative: four-year degree or you'll be a failure. "Pick something practical," they said, and then told me not to major in business, the one thing I actually wanted to study, because they didn't see it as practical. The irony is my mom was a principal at a vocational-technical school, surrounded by proof that trades can be high-value, high-income paths, and yet trades weren't even on the table for me. Rich and poor children are raised very differently when it comes to career expectations.

When I was younger, I was interested in enlisting in the military as a career and was told no. When I became scholarship material for ROTC, suddenly the military became acceptable, because it slotted neatly into the "respectable" script: officer, degree, benefits, pension. The MBA came next, not because I had some grand entrepreneurial plan, but because it was free via scholarship and my parents believed that stacking more degrees automatically meant more money. The middle class remains economically worse off despite higher education levels.

Here's the problem: degrees and "good jobs" do not protect you from bad financial decisions or an unsustainable lifestyle. A few years after the MBA, we were house poor and struggling to pay our bills. That was my personal wake-up call. Instead of doubling down on appearances, we tightened the reins, I went active duty from the Army Reserve, and we finally started building a life where we were more intentional with every dollar. My parents retired around 60. I want to be work-optional by 50 and never work for someone else again.

When you zoom out, you start to see the pattern: the middle class playbook delays or destroys wealth precisely because it feels so reasonable.

You're taught to chase the "sure thing" job and cling to it for decades, even if it caps your upside and kills your sense of agency. Entrepreneurship is seen as reckless rather than a skillset you can learn and scale.

You're encouraged to blow your limited vacation days (10 working days?!) and your savings on trips and upgrades because "you deserve it," rather than thinking, "How can I buy back more of my time permanently?"

You're told to save and avoid debt but never shown how to actually build wealth, no open talk about net worth, investing, or designing a life where work is optional.

Economists and sociologists have noted that class-based parenting styles often reproduce the same economic position across generations: middle class parents, trying to protect their kids, pass on a script that keeps them in the same lane, comfortable but never truly free, unless someone consciously breaks it.

For me, that breaking point came as I approached 40. I realized "midlife" is not 50; it's about 37. The idea of spending the rest of my finite time on earth laboring for someone else, trading my days for a salary and a pension, suddenly felt unbearable.

When I first started making adult money, I felt a quiet guilt and pressure to spend in ways that looked successful, newer cars, nicer stuff, keeping up with what people expected someone in my position to have. That's the middle class disease: caring deeply how your life looks while slowly losing control of how your life feels.

Now, I don't care. We make good money, more than my parents did at my age, even accounting for how much more expensive 2025 is than 2005 and we are deliberately choosing not to inflate our lifestyle to match our income. We could afford a much larger house. People expect us to, given my job. But the most precious thing isn't the big house and big payment; it's being able to step off the treadmill as soon as possible. Every time we say no to a bigger house or fancier car, we are saying yes to getting out of the rat race earlier.

Our kids are growing up in a normal neighborhood, not in some gated suburb that exists to stroke adult egos. The way we talk about money with them is the opposite of how money was handled in my childhood.

We do not buy them everything they want. They see friends who get anything on demand; we explain that's not how our house works.

We talk real numbers with them: how much the mortgage is, what utilities cost, what groceries cost, not to scare them, but to give them perspective on what adult life actually costs.

We explain that many people buy things with debt, which means they don't actually have the money. In our house, we save and buy things in cash when we can.

On education and work, the script is different too:

College: If you know what you want to do and can find a way to pay for it without wrecking your future, go for it. Your mom and I are not going into debt for you to chase a four-year degree (or play Ultimate Frisbee in the quad) just because it looks good.

Jobs: Find something that adds value. Take risks when you're young. Try new things. Job hop if you have to. Your first job is not your forever identity. We will always be here to support them and give a roof over their heads.

Entrepreneurship: The ultimate good feeling in life is creating something and adding value to society through a product or service that is yours. That is how generational wealth becomes possible, not through a slightly bigger salary, but through ownership.

We tell our kids plainly: we choose to buy and not buy certain things because we're building a life where we can be around you more. That's the point of money for us. Not to signal to other adults that we're winning, but to buy back our time as parents.

If you're reading this as a 35-year-old dad with a mortgage and kids, feeling that weird mix of gratitude and suffocation, this is for you. You did everything right according to the middle class rulebook, degree, job, house, vacations, and yet you still feel like you're running on a treadmill that never stops.

You are not crazy. The playbook is screwed-up.

You were raised to be a high-functioning, well-behaved employee in someone else's machine. You were trained to chase upgrades instead of ownership, respectability instead of autonomy, and pensions instead of real freedom. The only way this changes is if you decide, consciously, to stop passing that script on.

Have one honest money conversation with your kids this week. Tell them what something actually costs and how you decide whether it's worth it.

Write down the middle class scripts you inherited, "college at any cost," "bigger house equals success," "take the safe job," "vacations are where you blow money because you 'earned it'." Decide which one you'll break in the next 12 months.

Ask yourself one hard question: "Am I building a life where my kids learn to own their time and their work or am I just training them to become better-paid versions of me?"

Growing up middle class gave you comfort, safety, and a clear script. It did not give you freedom. Freedom is something you will have to build on purpose and it starts when you stop confusing looking successful with being truly wealthy in time, ownership, and presence.

The middle class money mistakes aren't about individual choices gone wrong. They're a system designed to keep you comfortable enough to never question it. You can break that cycle. You can teach your kids differently. You can choose ownership over employment, intentionality over consumption, and time with your family over a bigger house that keeps you trapped longer.

The question is: will you?

Know someone who need to read this? Help grow the OTW community and share it with a friend.